Wednesday, October 28, 2026

Coffee, Pastry, and Red Bricks: An Early Morning Guide to New Albany's Market Square

This is part ten of a travel series of our midwest road trip covering four states and two national parks.  We began our journey in Lake Geneva Wisconsin.  If you missed it, start HERE!

There is a quiet, postcard-perfect magic to New Albany, Ohio, just before the busyness of the weekday morning begins to stir.   The heart of the morning experience centers around Market Square, a beautiful Georgian-style district lined with classic red-brick storefronts.  Whether you are walking the brick-paved sidewalks with a fresh coffee in hand, admiring the architecture or floral displays;  a morning spent in New Albany is the ultimate way to experience Ohio's most charming neighborhood.
 

After two luxurious days in Mount Vernon Ohio, it was time to pack our bags and head to our next destination:  Columbus Ohio where we would visit the Botanical Gardens and the German Village.  But first, we had to make another stop along the way: New Albany which is  named America's #1 "suburb in America" by Business Insider.


New Albany is a master-planned community defined by its classical architecture, rich history, and manicured landscapes.  Residential and commercial buildings follow strict Neo-traditional design guidelines, primarily featuring Georgian-Palladian and Federal Style red-brick architecture paired with picket white fences.

The beauty of the red brick was striking.  Everything looked so new, clean, and pristine, but the concept was conceived and implemented in the 1990's. 

As much as I loved the architecture of New Albany, the gardener in me really appreciated the flowers!  Just look at these hanging baskets hanging from the old-fashioned street lamps.  Gorgeous.  Flower baskets, pots, window boxes, and gardens filled every nook and corner of Market Square.  It was like walking through a botanical garden.


We were there so early in the morning the only shops that were open were the coffee shops and the library.  Some of the shops include a toy store, an art gallery, a couple of women's clothing and accessory boutiques, a gift shop, two ice cream stores, and restaurants.


The New Albany Library sits proudly in the center of the shopping district right in front of the Village Green.

The New Albany library was opened in Market Square in 2003.  The original library first opened in 1998 as a joint-use school and public library at New Albany Public High School then later moved here.  It underwent a major renovation in 2021 but you wouldn't know it as the building's design looks like it has been here for ages.



The green space behind the library is Rose Run Park.  The Library Garden and Marx Reading Center is located right behind the library building.  This section features a scenic lawn, a birch-tree lined walk, patio space, and a reading terrace designed for outdoor library programs and relaxation.

The brick and iron footbridge spans across Rose Run Creek,  linking the library side of the corridor to the school campus and the Charleen and Charles Hinson Amphitheater. 


The Market Square shopping district mirrors an upscale, historic village rather than a modern commercial strip.  The brick-paved crosswalks, gas-style street lamps, and hidden courtyards reward early morning wanderers like my husband and I.


I found it ironic that although we were on our way to visit a botanical garden, I was also enjoying the flower gardens at New Albany's Market Square.  It was like watching a trailer to a coming attraction! 😀


I love how the chartreuse color of this plant coordinates with the chartreuse in the coleus planted beneath.


A central lawn with bright white benches and perfectly aligned trees separates the stores and library.  The Village Green hosts seasonal markets and events.  A flag pole is placed strategically in the center of The Village Green.


The transformation of New Albany, Ohio from a quiet rural town of fewer than 500 residents into one of the country's premier upscale master-planned communities was driven by the collaborative vision of retail billionaire Lex Wexner and real estate developer Jack Kessler.  Through The New Albany Company, founded in the mid-1980's they sought to entirely rethink modern suburban development.

Walking the brick paved streets of today's modern town, it's hard to believe New Albany was once a small farming town established in 1837 that has grown to a population of 11,770.


The lush, intentional landscaping changes with the seasons.  There are vibrant tulips in spring, cascading flowers in summer, and rich autumn displays.  We were visiting in mid-August when all the Viburnum bushes were in bloom.  The big, round blossoms soften the brick architecture, creating an inviting, walkable environment.


The apartments located directly across the street from Market Square had the same Georgian-style red brick.  I could easily see myself living there, so close to bike trails, parks, the library, and shopping. 


We were ecstatic to see our favorite chain restaurant, Mellow Mushroom in the square.  If only it were lunch time and we could enjoy a pizza!


Mellow Mushroom restaurants usually have a very bold, neon-colored, psychedelic design, which obviously is not allowed here.  But I loved how they still managed to stay true to their brand by keeping the retro 60's design yet softening the colors to fit in with the Federal-Style red brick architecture of Market Square.


Wexner and Kessler explicitly designed the community to reject post-WWII suburban sprawl.  Inspired by the historic countryside of Cotswold, England, they mandated a uniform, upscale aesthetic centered around Georgian Palladianism.   Every detail--from the multi-million dollar estates and Market Square storefronts to the iconic white equestrian fencing, historic street lamps, and wooden street signs--was meticulously planned to project timeless, classical luxury.


Rather than building disconnected residential subdivisions, the creators designed a cohesive lifestyle ecosystem.  They established a pedestrian-friendly layout centered around a walkable town center...Market Square.


To promote high quality life, the master plan integrated over 50 miles of leisure trails, extensive park systems, and cultural amenities like an amphitheater and a unified 120-acre public school campus.


Wexner and Kessler recognized that maintaining an elite school system and top-tier civic infrastructure required a massive, independent tax base.  Their vision included the creation of New Albany Business park which has grown to over 11,000 acres.  By attracting global tech giants like Microsoft, Meta, and Google for data centers, and anchoring a massive tech manufacturing boom highlighted by Intel's $20 billion semiconductor site, the park effectively funds the community's high-end residential amenities.

I know data centers are getting a bad rap these days, and I certainly understand the concerns, but when I see places like this where they really benefit the community if done right, it's hard for me to say "no" to data centers.


While the city is widely celebrated for its precise execution of "smart growth" design, its rapid corporate expansion has shifted the landscape from a purely pastoral country enclave into an industrial tech powerhouse.


Now after reading all the history of the town you are probably wondering what it costs to live here, I know I was!  The median household income is $200,001.  The average home ranges from $569,900 to $708,001...way out of my price range! 😀


New Albany is the dream that most Americans will never experience.  Their public schools are consistently rated in the top 3% of Ohio.  Every New Albany Plains Schools student attends class on a beautiful 200-acre learning campus that also includes an 80-acre nature preserve and wetlands area.  Wouldn't you love that for that your own children? 


New Albany also has over 81 miles of leisure trails and more than 2000 acres of park land.


Market Square has so many outdoor dining options for warm summer days.  Outdoor patios blend seamlessly with the classic brick architecture.  I loved how the shades of this restaurant can be opened or closed depending on the weather.  And the beautiful floral patio boxes can be enjoyed inside or out.


Stepping onto the dew-kissed red-brick sidewalks of this Georgian-style district the crisp morning air immediately guides you toward Fox in the Snow.  The aroma of freshly baked pastries and expertly crafted espresso pulls you into their beautiful rustic-modern space.  With a warm cup in hand and a world-class soufflé egg sandwich ready to enjoy, sitting outside among the elegant brick storefronts is the most delicious way to experience New Albany's signature charm.


Other than Starbucks, The Fox in the Snow seemed to be the busiest spot in Market Square when we were there.  We found the Fox emblem so interesting.  This Ohio store does not put their name on their storefronts, instead they paint a white fox (can you spot it in the photo above).  History tells us that the founders could not afford a sign when they opening their first location and instead hired a student to paint a simple illustration of a fox as its placeholder.

The inside of the restaurant had a modern industrial vibe which I loved.  Fox in the Snow does not have customer wi-fi which is an intentional, refreshing design choice that forces you away from your phone screen and into engaging with others while you enjoy delicious food and drinks.


The most famous item on the Fox in the Snow's menu is their Soufleed Egg Sandwich:  a central Ohio legend.  It features a perfectly thick, impossibly fluffy square of souffléd egg layered with melted Swiss cheese, sweet and smoky candied bacon, crisp arugula, and a zesty punch of Dijon mustard-mayo. Everything is cradled inside a tender, crackly-crusted ciabatta roll that holds it all together beautifully.

Unfortunately I already had breakfast that morning, so I could not eat a breakfast sandwich as much I wanted to try one.  Instead I chose one of their many Artisanal bakery items which are displayed in towering glass bakery cases and made fresh from scratch every morning.  My husband and I split a Blueberry Galette.  It cradles tart blueberries in a bed of rich vanilla cream cheese and flaky, sugar-encrusted dough.  YUM!  It was so so good it was heavenly!


Ultimately, New Albany's story is one of purposeful transformation, and nowhere is that more evident than in Market Square.  What began in 1837 as a modest farming crossroads has evolved into the vibrant, beating heart of the community.  Surrounded by the classic Georgian architecture that defines the city, Market Square seamlessly bridges New Albany's rich history with its modern energy.  

Have A Great Day!  Amy




                               Bridges, History, and College Towns:  Exploring the Kokosing Gap Trail 

         Beauty from Brick and Steel:  How an Abandoned Glass Factory Became a World-Class Park


No comments:

Post a Comment

Thank you for leaving a comment, I love feedback from my readers; but please don't include a hyperlink in the comments or I will have to delete it. You may include the name of your blog. If you have a blog, I always return the love by visiting within a week whoever leaves a comment.